Beware - Adsense and other ad networks may not be interested in your Android inventory

by bwilliam...@gmail.com » Wed, 29 Apr 2009 23:22:21 GMT


Sponsored Links
 I got banned by Adsense.  But this is not the post you think it is.  I
am not going to complain about the balance I'll never be paid for, nor
suggest that Adsense is a bunch of crooks, etc.  I just want to bring
light to another difficulty in monetizing Android applications to help
others keep their accounts from getting banned.

I have an app in the market, Real Estate Droid, that, at points, open
up Webviews with relevant information pulled from web services
(currently mortgage rates and property values, soon to include many
others).  The pages loaded contain responses to queries made from
inside the app.  This was working out very well for me, because the
pages were highly targeted to a valuable niche, giving me a very
satisfactory eCPM on Adsense.

Adsense does not approve of something I have done in conjunction with
this.  It is impossible to tell what they have a problem with, because
it is their policy not to describe why an account is disabled.  It
could have been any of the following (or anything else I haven't
thought of):

1) I chose to use Adsense for Content for these pages, rather than
Adsense for Mobile, because the Android browser is fully capable of
rendering traditional Adsense ads.
2) I forgot to display a privacy policy, though I fixed that in the
course of my appeal.
3) They do not consider the content to be rich enough to warrant
showing Adsense on it. (I kept the result pages relatively sparse in
order to fit on a 480x320 screen with minimal scrolling).
4) G1 traffic seems to be piped through a limited number of proxies,
so my traffic looks like it comes from 100 sources instead of 100000,
and thus looks invalid.

This is very unfortunate for me.  No other ad networks that I've found
(and I've looked into a LOT) offer the level of targeting or potential
revenue per click levels offered by Adsense, so my strategy of going
after a higher value/lower volume market is shot.  This also means
that I probably won't be able to take advantage of any Adsense Android
SDK that may be released in the future.

Another developer that I've been speaking to has used a somewhat
similar strategy for monetizing his free app - the high score page is
a web page that displays ads.  He's already been banned by 2 other ad
networks (with no explanation, of course).

So if I plan to do anything ad-supported on Android, I'm going to have
to go back to the model that has worked (well, at least somewhat) for
me so far - untargeted, high-volume stuff like my slot machine
application, using an Android SDK like Admob or Mojiva.

Or more likely, I'll port what I have already to iPhone and see if I
can accomplish something there.  iPhone seems to have much more mature
infrastructure for monetizing with ads, and fewer roadblocks (read:
Google Checkout) to users buying apps.  I'm not going to walk off in a
huff and swear never to come back (I'd be throwing away way too much
accumulated technical and domain expertise) but my hopes are growing
dimmer.

I wish you all continued luck in the request to entertain/inform some
mobile users and make a few bucks in the process.
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~



Other Threads

1. Including pre-compiled 3rd party jar files to android application & building it with source code

In Andoird APIDemos there is an application PlatformLibrary.

There he shows exactly how to use a Jar file to build our application.

Add an xml linking the path and add in the Android.mk,
Hope it helps
2009/10/21 Harsha <harsh...@gmail.com>



-- 
Shine bright,
(: Naveen Krishna Ch :)

--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~

2. Would you at least give us names

I know you have plans, but at least share with us who won in round 1.
Some of us have plans and need to know if they lost so they can start
selling their app or otherwise wait and keep their app free.
Instead of keeping thousands of users in the dark, announce the 200
and let others start planning.

This is really annoying, it's been almost three weeks and you won't
give information, you're delaying the release of the thousands of
application because of this! most developers will be annoyed when they
find out they lost and that they were waiting in vain.


--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~

3. OnLocationChanged never called

4. Modular packaging - Queries

5. ContentResolver in a Service

6. Will Android apps every make proper money ...

7. make seekbar (un)clickable depending on RadioButton