Problems with support from T-mobile/General Question

by Joseph G » Thu, 12 Mar 2009 10:18:47 GMT

Sponsored Links

I am having an issue that looks to be a bug on my Tmobile G1,  but T-
mobile isn't helping me resolve or expedite it.  The bug details are
listed here: 

T-mobile claims that I have the responsibility to troubleshoot Android
and file bugs for a phone they "support" and run on their network.
Humorously enough I went to the Better Business Bureau and so they
finally got back to me after 5 separate calls to support.  They claim
2 things that I am wondering about...

1. Do providers have responsiblity for interfacing with you the
Android team in submitting bugs on behalf of their supported
consumers?  Or does the consumer?

2. Do you have a team within the Android group at Google that works
with the provider networks?

BTW, the particular "senior" customer service manager I spoke with
said that the issue related to the fact that Android was open source.
Being a user, supporter and advocate of FOSS I had to stop and laugh.
xD  I asked him what that had to do with it and I got no response.


Problems with support from T-mobile/General Question

by Dave Sparks » Thu, 12 Mar 2009 12:45:12 GMT

 I can't comment on T-Mobile's obligations to you - that is determined
by the terms of the agreement you signed when you signed up. The
Android team does have liaisons who work with the carriers and device
manufacturers and we receive bug reports from them.


Sponsored Links

Problems with support from T-mobile/General Question

by Al Sutton » Thu, 12 Mar 2009 15:10:26 GMT

 I think 1 is best answered by a lawyer.

As for 2; Google works with the providers, but what the providers ship 
is the providers decision and not Googles.



* Written an Android App? - List it at  *

Funky Android Limited is registered in England & Wales with the 
company number  6741909. The registered head office is Kemp House, 
152-160 City Road, London,  EC1V 2NX, UK. 

The views expressed in this email are those of the author and not 
necessarily those of Funky Android Limited, it's associates, or it's 


Problems with support from T-mobile/General Question

by Joseph G » Fri, 13 Mar 2009 00:21:27 GMT

 Hello Dave/Al/ Everyone,

Thanks for taking the time to answer my questions.   If anyone
actually knows about how I should deal with situation please respond
to me off list.

No one else found it funny that T-mobile said the issues of the device
were BECAUSE it was open source!?  I just about had a laughing fit.



Problems with support from T-mobile/General Question

by Justin Allen Jaynes » Fri, 13 Mar 2009 07:21:42 GMT


In a certain sense, the T-Mobile G1 version of Android ISN'T open 
source.  It WAS open source (under the Apache style license) until they 
commercialized the code and placed their own variant of Android onto the 
phone.  Which is perfectly fine.  That's a major reason it's licensed 
with the Apache instead of the GPL.  There is NO WAY TMobile would 
supply you with the source code they used to build the versions of the 
OS which run on their supported devices.  It's now in a closed system.

Now that they have done so, they dang well better support it for their 
paying customers-- or notify the users at the time of purchase that the 
phone itself is not officially supported.

Nevertheless, I'm not at all surprised.  I never could get support for a 
bug in my ultra basic Samsung phone who's calendar puts schedules on the 
wrong days.  I verified the bug with customer support and they claimed 
it was just my tuff luck.  I fought back and got another phone model at 
a steep discount.  But I still had to hand over money.  It's just the 
way the world works.



Other Threads

1. Google makin cihuy, Bakal Scan 400 ribu buku

Wow, Google Bakal Scan 400.000 Buku

  Google akan mengongkosi digitalisasi koleksi perpustakaan Austria yang
menghabiskan sekitar 50-100 euro per buku.

VIENNA. Perpustakaan nasional Austria telah meneken kontrak senilai 30 juta
euro dengan raksasa internet asal AS, Google, untuk mendigitalisasi 400.000
buku-buku yang bebas hak cipta atau *copyright-free books.* Buku-buku
tersebut merupakan koleksi sejarah Eropa dalam 400 tahun terakhir.

Johanna Rachinger, Kepala ONB Library, menyebut hal ini sebagai 'langkah
penting' lantaran perpustaaan Austria merupakan satu dari lima perpustakaan
yang menyimpan koleksi terbesar dari abad 16-19. Jika dihitung, koleksi buku
tersebut tak kurang dari 120 juta halaman.

Dibawah kesepakatan dengan Google, nantinya Google akan mengongkosi
digitalisasi koleksi perpustakaan Austria yang menghabiskan sekitar 50-100
euro per buku. Pihak perpustakaan menyatakan, tanpa adanya pendanaan
eksternal, hal ini tidak bisa terwujud.

Google akan mulai men-scan pada tahun 2011 di Bavaria dan diperkirakan akan
rampung dalam 6 tahun. Hanya saja, Google tak akan punya hak eksklusif
terhadap buku-buku yang sudah di scan tersebut. Nantinya, semua koleksi
tersebut bisa diakses melalui situs ONB di, Google Books
Library di maupun kewilayahan Eropa di

Google telah men-scan jutaan buku untuk membikin perpustakaan digital maupun
toko buku online. Sayangnya, proyek macam ini sering terganjal kontroversi
dari hak cipta, anti-trust dan isu privasi.

Hitung punya hitung, Google sudah men-scan 12 juta buku dari 40
perpustakaan, termasuk Universitas Stanford dan Harvard di AS, dan juga
Universitas Rome dan Florence di Italia.

Femi Adi Soempeno, AFP

Perpustakaan Indonesia kapan ya? hehe


"Indonesian Android Community [id-android]" 

2. OOT : Kecewa dengan TELKOMSEL

maaf om, udah di ganti subject nya tuh, heheheee.....
tambahan klo ga cocok dari masalah room berarti ga bisa buat telpon dong
dari kmrn2... ini kan kejadiannya pas tadi malam aja. sampe skrng  :( tapi
klo di ganti pake simpati normal

2010/6/17 Iwan H <>


3. Mobile Broadband buat Androi

4. Kecewa dengan TELKOMSEL

5. sensor calibration file

6. Font gmail apps

7. Singapura --- Ini Ponsel Lho