Android: why not just improve JME or phoneME?

by bboyes » Thu, 03 Sep 2009 00:15:32 GMT


Sponsored Links
 > What I didnt like is this redefiniton of concepts like events etc. I

I have wondered the same thing since all my experience to date is with
J2ME on industrial embedded systems (not phone aps). Phone apps use
PhoneME which is much more restricted than the embedded Java systems
we use. We must have access to the hardware, file system, low level
event and interrupt access, etc to support I/O devices which vary from
application to application.

What strikes me is that phoneME is stuck in the past, whereas Android
assumes some current hardware base. phoneME lets you run one app at a
time with strong sandbox restrictions, no data sharing, no built in
database, and you need a dozen JSRs to support everything (ref the
high end Sony phones like K850 which still has no keyboard, dinky
screen, no touch support). It's a painful environment in which to make
something useful. Plus if you want to license phoneME you must shell
out around US$100K to Sun for a full JME license. You can't just get
part for less (say you just want the Squawk VM to build SunSPOTS).
It's all or nothing. So clearly Sun does not want every small company
in the world deploying JME commercially. Check out the headache Bug
Labs had with that.

I blogged a bit about this: 
 http://techbleat.blogspot.com/2009/07/using-small-java-commercially-bring.html. 

So it is fascinating that Eric Schmidt (once the manager of Java
development at Sun!) chose to NOT license JME from Sun (http://
techbleat.blogspot.com/2009/07/what-happened-to-love.html) but to roll
Dalvik instead. I can see why Google chose to step into the present
instead of suffering with limits that made sense 10+ years ago...
still, it's a valid question, and a real shame that Sun could not work
together with Google, IBM, and others to make Squawk or JME much more
like what Android is now. Perhaps that is part of why they got snapped
up by Oracle at a bargain-basement price, and why my Sun stock is
worth 10% of what I paid.
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~



Other Threads

1. Problem downloading files

Since I installed someapp (don't know which app did this) everytime I
try to download an MKV file on the default web browser it changes the
extension to TXT how can I fix this? thanks in advance.

Using: Xperia 10, Android OS 1.6

-- 

2. Apps interaction

Hi all.
I've seen a beta version of Navigator from Google.
Since I've read some Android's book, I know about intents and actions.

I'm wondering if there's a way to know, more generally, how to use a
particular application from others.

For instance, with Navigator I would add my own "Point of Interest"
taken from a web service, or dinamically build a trip.

Will this be possible ? Where I can find more documentation about
entry points of existing apps ?

Hope the question is clear enough.

Best Regards
FabioG

-- 

3. Local HTML files displayable application

4. Debug Rild

5. Hello World C program using Android Toolchain Issue

6. what is invokeOemRilRequestStrings supposed to do?

7. Bouncing ListView Effect