Timer / threads / reliability

by Neilz » Fri, 05 Mar 2010 00:12:02 GMT

Sponsored Links
 Hi all. I have an activity that uses a Timer (java.util.Timer) to
control the display. I set it off to repeat its run() method every
second or so. When it runs, it updates some View elements.

As Timer runs in its own thread, I assumed this would be reliable. But
I notice that sometimes there is a stutter, or delay, in the views
updating. It's like they occasionally get stacked up, and all happen
together. Studying the output from logcat, I notice that this happens
when the device is doing something else - some system functions, or
sometimes a garbage collection.

How can I avoid this? I'm not aware I can run the main activity in a
thread of its own, can I? If the timer has its own thread, why is it

Any help appreciated!


Timer / threads / reliability

by Mark Murphy » Fri, 05 Mar 2010 00:20:49 GMT


You can't.

Because the UI is drawn on the main application thread.

Whenever you make a change to the UI -- such as calling setText() on a
TextView -- think of it as putting a message on a message queue that is
processed in a message loop by the main application thread.

All your Timer is doing is triggering some messages to go into that
queue on a periodic basis. How quickly those messages will be popped off
the queue and processed depends on what else is in the queue, how much
time those other things in the queue take (including time in your
activity and listener callback methods), what else is being done in
threads in your application, and what else is being done in other
processes on the device.

You can simplify your current implementation by dumping the Timer and
using postDelayed() to trigger your updates, for what that's worth.

Mark Murphy (a Commons Guy)
 http://commonsware.com  |  http://twitter.com/commonsguy 

Android App Developer Training:  http://commonsware.com/training 


Sponsored Links

Timer / threads / reliability

by Neilz » Fri, 05 Mar 2010 01:46:29 GMT

 Thanks Mark, that makes sense. So basically, I should be implementing
a View with its own draw() method, run in a thread, as in the various
game examples.

I presume from your comment below that using postDelayed() isn't
really going to solve my problem.


Timer / threads / reliability

by Mark Murphy » Fri, 05 Mar 2010 01:55:40 GMT


No, it'd just negate the need for a separate Timer.

Mark Murphy (a Commons Guy)
 http://commonsware.com  |  http://twitter.com/commonsguy 

Android App Developer Training:  http://commonsware.com/training 


Timer / threads / reliability

by Neilz » Sat, 27 Mar 2010 17:24:53 GMT

 Ok, reviving an older thread.

Is there a way, to have View elements (TextView, Button, whatever)
that are not run on the main UI thread?

What about if I set up a game thread, with its own View (like in the
LunarLander sample, for instance) and then create View elements on the
fly and attach them to the main View? Are these still going to be run
in the main UI thread, or in the game thread?



Timer / threads / reliability

by Mark Murphy » Sat, 27 Mar 2010 19:00:32 GMT



Neither. Your application will crash.

You cannot modify the widget-based UI from a background thread.

Now, I cannot speak for 2D (Canvas) or 3D (OpenGL) apps and what their
limitations are vis a vis threads. I am only talking about using Views.

Mark Murphy (a Commons Guy)
 http://commonsware.com  |  http://twitter.com/commonsguy 

_Android Programming Tutorials_ Version 2.0 Available!


Timer / threads / reliability

by Kevin Duffey » Sun, 28 Mar 2010 02:55:36 GMT

 The stutter, from what I've picked up on other threads, is as Mark said, due
to various other tasks, apps, and more likely garbage collection kicking in
randomly. One thing that seems to be a common thread for most "real-time"
like UI updating games is to do some sort of time based setup. I forget the
details, but basically on each iteration, you figure out the current time,
subtract the last "time" that was stored, that tells you how much elapsed
time has passed. You use this value to adjust all your UI elements so that
rather than seeing a hiccup with the UI, they UI elements themselves "speed
up" at various times. Or..maybe speed up isn't the right word. But lets say
you have a UI element moving from left to right, 1 pixel per second. A GC
hits and causes a 3 second delay. Your UI element hasn't moved for 3
seconds. In the time based method, you would instead move the UI element 3
pixels so that it would be where it should be. The hiccup would still be
noticeable.. but at least your UI elements will be where they should be,
rather than lagging behind where they should be causing more problems.

There are some threads, and Robert Green and some others have info on here
on how to do it. I've yet to really figure out how to apply the difference
between two frames time stamps and apply it to the world-coordinate system
of a View, for example to make sure a UI element moves to the right

If you are making a sort of game, one of the other important things to do is
do NO creation of objects in the loop. Do all pre-allocation of elements,
objects etc before your loop starts.. or between levels, etc. That makes
game levels generally small in size based on the very limited 16MB ram (or
is it 24MB) you can use for game + images + code... but at least if you can
avoid any sort of object allocation/deallocation during the loop, you can
put off the GC process longer. At least for your game. There was a thread
that was pretty deep on the issue of background services running that could
also trigger a GC and cause your game to hiccup.. and the general solution
to come of that was Google needs to make some sort of "real-time" game mode
so that games that we see on iPhone will be possible on Android. Right now
there seems to be no way to guarantee smooth real-time-ish games on Android.
Some do a very good job tho.


Timer / threads / reliability

by Dianne Hackborn » Sun, 28 Mar 2010 16:50:56 GMT


Windows can run in their own threads, all views inside of a particular
window must run in the same thread.  The window associated with an Activity
is created in the main thread of its process, so that is where its UI runs.
 You can run windows in other threads if you use Looper to prepare and run a
message loop in that thread, and then instantiate and display the window

SurfaceView also is often used to do UI from a separate thread, by letting
the other thread have the Surface to draw into it (either via the Canvas or
OpenGL APIs).  This also allows you to draw without going through updates,
though doesn't allow you to use a regular view hierarchy in the surface.

Dianne Hackborn
Android framework engineer

Note: please don't send private questions to me, as I don't have time to
provide private support, and so won't reply to such e-mails.  All such
questions should be posted on public forums, where I and others can see and
answer them.


Other Threads

1. How can I upload a device recorded Video to a specific YoutTube account?

Hello everyone,

I have read previous posts that somehow mention how to upload videos
to YouTube, but I would like to get the whole picture of what I
mention, considering new OS versions have been released:

Is it possible to record a video directly from the device, and then
use some sort of Android native intent, to upload this video to a
specific YouTube account (not the device owner), being able to tell if
the upload was succesful and retrieving the appropriate YouTube video

If not, what is the most appropriate way to upload a video to
YouTube?  Do I have to do it using the GData API (Java)?  Is there an
example available on how to do it?

Thanks in advance for your help!

Best regards,



2. Disable Home Key?


I am doing a security Lock system for my project. I am interested to
know how to disable the HOME key or handle it at framework layer, in
order to prevent user to by pass the security lock by presing HOME. I
know that I am not able to do it at android application layer, so
thinking to get some tips in handling it in framework layer.



3. In call screen

4. currentTimeMillis() doesnt match on two concurrent emulators

5. How to slip right/left to review next/previous item in the listview?

6. Programmatically setting a new default ringtone without the ringtone picker

7. How to prevent long URL from breaking in generated email?